And, the first item on the invalid use list is the user-submitted forum content. If anything changes in the future, I can implement whatever changes. But, for now, the only valid schema for topics is DiscussionForumPosting, and FAQPage is not allowed for forums. And, trust me, Google knows where the schemas are used, and they can ban whole websites from using snippets for violations. It is a bad idea to use the wrong snippets.

But i is more QAPAGE

No no the seo logic from guillaume Deplanque is correct, see https://neilpatel.com/blog/faq-schema/amp/
Many seo experts think DiscussionForumPosting will be unsupported. Regards

Google doesn’t like when you use snippets wrong, and QAndA is not for this purpose. Rich snippet for topics is ‘DiscussionForumPosting’, and I don’t plan to implement something that doesn’t fit the content. And, QAndA has a very specific structure that replies can’t fit.

ah ok
so “reply” has not rich snippet ?
and is it possible to implement QandA snippets for topic and reply.
according some seo experts blogs posts it is better than simple forum snippets.
thank you

Hi,

GD bbPress Toolbox Pro already has support for Rich Snippet for topics. Topics are only part of forums that have dedicated rich snippets, and that has been implemented a while back.

Milan

OK I see
i have a suggestion : maybe you could add a feature for having rich snippet in bbpress
i think you already have for breabcrump, maybe having for subject / topics and repply would be awsome because it is a missing bbpress feature. i ‘am thinking about “how to “, forum, article and blog (because sometime news are in forums topic) .
what do you think about it ?
thank you

Hi,

For this, bbPress templates have to be replaced, and that would make it impossible to have themes with bbPress support these custom templates. The best way to do it is by overriding templates via theme. Because of that, I do not add any feature to GD bbPress Toolbox Pro that requires replacing default bbPress templates.

Milan

Thanks for the suggestion. But, that is very, very complicated to achieve as a universal feature (that will work for all sorts of use cases), and it poses tons of issues (how to determine related data, where do the results come from…). It is not something that can be achieved as a universally usable feature and not something I can or will add to this plugin.

It can be a custom mode plugin that works on a strictly defined scope and with a strictly defined data source.

Yes thank you , a tool in toolbox pro to have relation in bbpress
example : in a topic, an user writter about a movie, in sidebar or bottom of the topic, we could see review about this movies, topic about actor fo this movie, etc
thanks 🙂

Hey, thanks for the comment. I am not sure what you mean exactly with this suggestion, can you explain better?

ok amazing feature i hope you will do.
i hope that and a related item field for bbpress

Hi,

Thanks for the suggestion! This is not something that many users would understand to use, this is more of the administrator/moderator useful tool. Right now, plugin can reformat the topic title for use in the meta title field to use forum name along with the topic title, and I am open to adding more things there, but I am not sure when that will be possible.

Regards,
Milan